# Changelog

> **This is the PUBLIC form of this artifact. Findings are listed in full, but the details of SECURITY findings — which rule fired, in which file, on which line, and how to fix it — are deliberately withheld, and any secret-scanner results are excluded entirely. Where detail is absent here it was REMOVED FOR PUBLICATION; it is not missing from the analysis. The complete artifact is available from the repository owner.**

## Score

- CAI 39 → 38 (-0.4)
- Rubric changed (rubric-2026.10.5 → rubric-2026.11.2) — scores are not directly comparable.

## Lenses

- Code Health 36 → 36 (-0.1)
- Architecture 86 → 85 (-1.1)
- Maturity 38 → 62 (+24.2)
- Readiness 62 → 62 (-0.3)
- Security 50 → 47 (-2.8)
- Domain Modelling 100 → 100 (+0.0)
- Accessibility 33 → 27 (-5.7)

## Resolved (22)

- Duplicate intent across plugin namespaces. While the methods are namespaced to specific plugins, the pattern `settings()` and `save_settings()` is repeated identically in `Attack` and `FrontCache`. This suggests a missing base interface or shared concern for plugin admin settings, leading to code duplication rather than polymorphic consistency.
- High CVE: [GHSA redacted] (yarn.lock)
- Hotspot: app/models/camaleon_cms/ability.rb (app/models/camaleon_cms/ability.rb)
- Hotspot: app/models/concerns/camaleon_cms/site_default_settings.rb (app/models/concerns/camaleon_cms/site_default_settings.rb)
- Hotspot: lib/camaleon_cms/uploader_pipeline.rb (lib/camaleon_cms/uploader_pipeline.rb)
- Inconsistent lifecycle method naming. `destroy` is standard Rails for permanent deletion. `trash` and `restore` are specific to soft-delete patterns. However, `PostsController` exposes `trash` and `restore` as top-level actions, while other controllers (e.g., `CategoriesController`, `CommentsController`) use `destroy` for deletion. This inconsistency makes it unclear if the system uses soft-delete universally or only for posts.
- Inconsistent naming convention for similar operations. `AuthoringPostHelper` uses `plugin_authoring_new_post` while `VisibilityPostHelper` uses `plugin_visibility_new_post`. While the prefix distinguishes the plugin, the verb 'new' is often used for form rendering (GET) in Rails, whereas 'create' is for persistence (POST). If these are both form renderers, 'new' is consistent. If one is creation and one is rendering, it's inconsistent. Given the presence of `create_post` in both, `new_post` likely implies 'render new form'. However, the naming `plugin_<type>_new_post` is verbose and inconsistent with standard Rails `new` vs `create` separation if the signatures differ in intent. More critically, `AuthoringPostHelper` has `plugin_authoring_create_post` AND `plugin_authoring_new_post`, while `VisibilityPostHelper` also has both. The inconsistency is subtle but the naming `plugin_<plugin>_new_post` is non-standard compared to standard `new` actions.
- Inconsistent signature for reorder operations. `NavMenusController` takes explicit arguments `items, parent_id, is_root`, while `SidebarController.reorder()` likely relies on params or a different internal structure (signature not fully shown but implied by lack of args in the list). This creates an inconsistent API for clients or internal callers trying to reorder different types of lists.
- Off-boarding risk: anonymized user #1
- Outdated: brakeman
- Outdated: cancancan
- Outdated: meta-tags
- Outdated: mini_magick
- Outdated: net-http
- Outdated: rails
- Outdated: rspec_junit_formatter
- Outdated: rubocop
- Outdated: rubocop-capybara
- Outdated: rubocop-rails
- Outdated: rubocop-rspec_rails
- …and 2 more

## New (10)

- High: security finding (details withheld)
- High: security finding (details withheld)
- High: security finding (details withheld)
- Off-boarding risk: anonymized user #1
- Orphaned file (app/decorators/camaleon_cms/post_type_decorator.rb)
- Outdated: rspec-rails
- doc comments repeat the names (app/assets/javascripts/camaleon_cms/admin/_libraries.js)
- redundant comment (app/assets/javascripts/camaleon_cms/admin/_translator.js)
- redundant comment (app/assets/javascripts/camaleon_cms/admin/lte/app.js)
- redundant comment (app/assets/javascripts/camaleon_cms/admin/nav_menu.js)

## Changes since last survey

- 98 commits — 90 feature/other, 8 fixes

## By area

- (root) — 23 commits
- (repo) — 16 commits
- openspec/changes — 16 commits
- .claude/skills — 8 commits
- docs/upgrading-to-2.9.5.md — 6 commits
- .github/workflows — 4 commits
- spec/requests — 4 commits
- app/assets — 3 commits
- app/controllers — 3 commits
- app/helpers — 3 commits
- app/models — 3 commits
- docs/ai — 2 commits
- config/locales — 1 commit
- docs/security — 1 commit
- lib/camaleon_cms — 1 commit
- spec/lib — 1 commit
- spec/models — 1 commit
- spec/skills — 1 commit
- spec/support — 1 commit

## Notable commits

- fix: Fix the group 1 sample in the comment of set_field_value
- fix: Merge pull request #1320 from owen2345/fix/review-loop-commit-rule
- fix: Merge pull request #1327 from owen2345/fix/review-loop-scripts
- fix: Merge pull request #1332 from owen2345/fix/captcha-text-quoting
- fix: Merge pull request #1333 from owen2345/fix/set-field-values-string-keys
- fix: Merge pull request #1335 from owen2345/fix/xhr-admin-save-refusal-answer
- fix: Merge pull request #1336 from owen2345/fix/custom-fields-render-malformed-field-options
- fix: Phase 3 and AGENTS.md: related fixes share a commit, and the checks run once before it
- change: Add the changelog entry for the Rails 8.1.4.1 bump
- change: Add the changelog entry for the Ruby and Bundler upgrade
- change: Add the changelog entry for the development lock update
- change: Add the changelog entry for the nokogiri, loofah and rails-html-sanitizer bumps
- change: Add the changelog entry for the rack and addressable bumps
- change: Add the changelog entry of PR #1336
- change: Add the changelog entry of the String keys read of set_field_values
- change: Add the changelog entry of the XHR refusal answer
- change: Add the changelog entry of the captcha text quoting
- change: Add the changelog entry of the ci-rerun script
- change: Add the changelog entry of the review-loop scripts
- change: Add the ci-rerun script of the review loop
- …and 78 more

## Architecture

- Unchanged — 0 containers · 1 contexts · 0 edges
